Pranking the Masses
Article

Pranking the Masses

By Carrie Cummings on Oct 23, 2013

Prankvertising, or stuntvertising, is nothing new in the media world. It’s been going on for years—decades even—for viewers’ pleasure. Per usual, as with any trend, the advertising community has co-opted the public’s fascination with embarrassing, tricking and terrifying unsuspecting strangers and turned it into a profitable, and many times viral, way to promote their clients’ products. Most recently, Thinkmodo promoted the Carrie remake with a terrifying coffee shop prank (see above) that instantly went viral.

Is this way of business cheap and mean, or deliciously brilliant? We asked two creatives, Andy Azula of The Martin Agency and Jimmy Smith of Amusement Park Entertainment, along with media psychologist Pamela Rutledge what they think about this trend.
 
 

Andy Azula, Creative Director, The Martin Agency

The desire to watch other people get pranked is as old as TV. Today’s “prankvertising” is simply Candid Camera with product placement. And until someone gets hurt, the only people alienated are probably the prankees (we have Brazil and other countries with fewer lawyers to thank for fueling the trend and upping the ante).

I do believe these things can help sales when the concept (prank) is tied to the product. Nivea and LG did this well. LG demonstrated the quality of the product. And I imagine after overcoming the shock of watching the world end, those people left wanting to buy that TV.  More importantly, it made me consider buying one.

I thought the Carrie stunt was brilliant, and it is still attracting tons of eyeballs. I only wish it resolved the prankee’s delimina. The only connection to the actual movie is line about how “there are other people out there like me...” Miss that, and you’ve missed the concept. Anyhow, we are probably only one emotional distress lawsuit away from larger brands being willing to pull off stunts like these.



Jimmy Smith, Chairman, CEO & CCO of Amusement Park Entertainment

From the award shows I've judged this season, I can see lots of peeps are joining the prankvertising bandwagon.  Obviously, it's the hot new thang.  But in reality, like branded entertainment (Read up on "Popeye the Sailor Man") prankvertising isn't all that new. Anyone remember the marketing/advertising campaign for the Blair Witch Project
 
In 1999, Haxan Films and Artisan Entertainment convinced many, including myself, that there was a witch in the woods and they had the documentary footage to prove it! From Wikipedia: "The Blair Witch Project is thought to be the first widely released movie marketed primarily by internet. The movie's official website featured fake police reports and 'newsreel-style' interviews. Due to this, some people initially thought it was an actual documentary about the 'missing' teenagers. These augmented the movie's found footage style to spark debates across the internet over whether the movie was a real-life documentary or a work of fiction."
 
Prankvertising has evolved. Ad heads have borrowed from Ashton Kutcher's Punk'd (which borrowed heavily from Allen Funt's Candid Camera).
 
But I'm not sippin' Hater-Ade. Most of the work I've seen, such as LG's Meteor, Carrie's Telekenesis, Heineken's The Candidate and Carlsberg's Poker, is selling, award winning and off the skillet.
 
However, like with any trend, whether it's old school or new school, folks are going to have to work harder and harder so that the trend remains surprising.
 
That's no easy trick!



Pamela Rutledge, Director, Media Psychology Research Center

This type of stunvertising promotion breaks the fourth wall, bringing a story into the real world as the theater. 
 
However, unlike the current movement toward creating coordinated and immersive stories across multiple media channels, often called transmedia storytelling, stuntvertising takes advantage of the audience’s lack of knowledge rather than inviting them to participate. 
 
If the experience is legitimate (and I have seen some indications that people believe the whole thing was staged with actors), the audience doesn’t know that an event or stunt is taking place which means we are being entertained at their expense. Even if someone is suspicious, any hostile or fearful multi-sensory event triggers our primal survival instincts. Before anyone can consciously override the response because they suspect a fake, his/her cortisol and adrenaline would react. 
 
At a time when we have orange alerts and Boston Marathon bombers, a prank like this is unkind even potentially dangerous.  It raises additional questions if children were present.  In terms of cognitive development, younger children may not be able to distinguish reality from fiction—even if everyone else had a good laugh at the end.
 
The video will go viral for multiple reasons; however, most of it will be to see how bad was it and how they did it. No one likes to be tricked or manipulated. It is a hostile thing to do. So while Sony may have created some buzz around the Carrie remake, it does not build much audience affection. In fact, I would argue that they have distanced themselves from a large segment of a customer base because the new ethic of social technologies is based on respect, trust and authenticity. 

 






Tags

Share To

Related

George Lois Keynote - 2017 Creative Summit George Lois discusses the origination and development of 27 newly discovered sketches of his classic Esquire covers from The George Lois Big Idea Archives at CCNY.
Nick Law Keynote - 2017 Creative Summit Does the Art and Copy team that launched the creative revolution 60 years ago have a future? If not, who will make the stuff that tomorrow’s audience will care about? How will they work and what will their work look like? Nick Law, Vice Chairman and Global Chief Creative Officer, R/GA, will do his best to answer these questions.
Cadillac Keynote - 2017 Creative Summit Melody Lee, Director of Brand Marketing at Cadillac presents at the 2017 Creative Summit. Cadillac was for many years synonymous with the American Dream. But as consumer tastes and the world changed, that Dream became less well-defined. Find out how Cadillac’s latest campaign captures their view of what inspires today’s consumers and how they’re redefining the luxury market.
2017 One Show Awards Ceremony - May 12 The One Show is one of the most prestigious awards competitions in advertising, design, interactive and branded entertainment. Judged every year by top industry professionals, a Gold Pencil is the ultimate symbol of creative excellence. In 2017 The One Show includes new categories and a new structure, highlighting work in key verticals such as automotive, consumer packaged goods and retail. This year also sees the return of the Penta Pencil, which was launched last year to recognize the best, most creative partnerships between client and agency spanning at least 5 years.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Follow Us